Top Cake Flavours Our Customers Love (And Why They Keep Reordering)

There’s something magical about a cake that tastes just right. At The Bakistry, we’ve noticed patterns in what our customers keep coming back for — flavours that are classic, indulgent, and universally loved. Here’s a look at the top picks and why they’re so popular.

1. Chocolate Cake

Why it’s loved:
Rich, moist, and indulgent, our chocolate cake is a favourite for all ages. Perfect for birthdays, office celebrations, or just a sweet treat, it’s paired with smooth chocolate buttercream or ganache for that extra wow factor.

Best for: Express Cakes, Gateaux, Cupcakes

2. Vanilla Buttercream Cake

Why it’s loved:
Simple, elegant, and endlessly versatile, vanilla buttercream is a crowd-pleaser. It’s light, fluffy, and easy to pair with decorations, themes, or personal messages.

Best for: Budget Express Cakes, Classic Cakes, Treat Slices

3. Red Velvet Cake

Why it’s loved:
A touch of luxury and colour makes red velvet irresistible. Its subtle cocoa flavour and creamy frosting are perfect for birthdays, romantic occasions, or festive celebrations.

Best for: Express Cakes, Gateaux, Cupcakes

4. Cookies & Cream

Why it’s loved:
The playful mix of chocolate cookies and creamy frosting makes this a hit with kids and adults alike. Fun, indulgent, and visually appealing — it’s often ordered in combination with cupcakes or treats.

Best for: Cupcakes, Treats & Slices, Combos

5. Chocolate Caramel

Why it’s loved:
Sweet, rich, and decadent, chocolate caramel is perfect for those who want something a little more indulgent. Its layered textures and flavours make it a show-stopper for special occasions.

Best for: Gateaux, Celebration Cakes, Combos

How to Pick Your Favourite

If you can’t decide, don’t worry — you don’t have to choose just one flavour. Many customers combine options: a classic chocolate cake as the centerpiece with cupcakes in vanilla or red velvet for variety.

Our Combos and Treats & Slices are perfect for trying multiple flavours in one order.

Why Our Customers Keep Coming Back

Every cake from The Bakistry is:

• Freshly baked with quality ingredients
• Beautifully finished for any occasion
• Delivered fast and reliably

No matter the flavour, we ensure every cake tastes as good as it looks.

Ready to Order?

Explore our Express Cakes, Gateaux, and Cupcakes to pick your favourite flavour — or try something new today.

Fresh. Fast. Beautifully Made.